If you have never sold coins, gold, jewelry, silver, or collectibles before, there is a good chance some of your expectations come from television or YouTube.

That is understandable. Shows about pawn shops and collectibles can be entertaining. They need unusual items, dramatic negotiations, experts walking through the door, and a little suspense before the commercial break.

Real transactions are usually much more straightforward.

There will be no dramatic music playing while we look at your collection. We are not going to pretend to walk away three times. We are not going to move our offer up and down by thousands of dollars just to make the conversation more exciting.

We are simply trying to figure out what your items are worth and whether we can make a fair transaction.

What Actually Happens When You Bring Something In

Many of the things people bring us are items we see every day. Common U.S. coins, gold jewelry, silver coins, bullion, sterling silver, and older paper money usually do not require a dramatic investigation.

We identify the item, check the current market, consider its condition and resale demand, and make an offer.

Sometimes something unusual comes through the door and we are not immediately certain what it is worth. In that case, we may look through auction records, check recent sales, consult reference books, or contact someone who knows more about that particular area.

Occasionally, I do call a friend.

It is usually a quick text message or a short phone call. There is no grand entrance by a celebrity expert. We are simply trying to get accurate information before making an offer.

That is one major difference between entertainment and an actual business. Television has to turn the research into part of the show. We just need the answer.

Another television-style idea we sometimes hear is, “Let’s flip a coin for the higher price.”

We do not do that.

A coin toss might make a good video clip, but it is not a sensible way to determine what something is worth. Our offers are based on the item, the current market, our expected resale price, and the costs and risks involved in buying it.

We are not gambling with your money or ours.

We also occasionally meet people who approach the negotiation as though they are playing poker. They may give us a very high number even though they would gladly accept much less.

For example, someone might say they are looking for $1,200. We research the item and find that similar examples are selling for around $800. We explain that we cannot go anywhere near $1,200 but may be able to offer around $600.

They immediately agree and then tell us another dealer already offered $500.

We understand the thinking. People are often told to ask high, never make the first offer, and never reveal what someone else offered.

But most collectible markets are not completely mysterious. We are often looking at the same auction results, precious-metal prices, dealer bids, and recent sales that anyone else can find.

We generally prefer a more direct conversation.

If another shop offered you $500, it is perfectly fine to tell us. We will see whether we can beat it. Sometimes we can. Sometimes we cannot. If the other offer is stronger than what we can reasonably pay, we may simply tell you to take it.

Saying, “I do not know what it is worth,” is also a perfectly reasonable answer. Many people genuinely have no idea what they inherited or found in a drawer. That is part of why they came to see us.

When we ask what you are hoping to get, we are not necessarily trying to discover the lowest number you will accept. We are often trying to determine whether our understanding of the item and your expectations are somewhere in the same universe.

We see enormous differences in expectations. One person may believe an item is worth almost nothing. Another person may believe a common item is worth thousands of dollars because of an online video or an unrealistic asking price they found on eBay.

A quick, honest conversation can save everyone time.

Our goal is not to create suspense. We are just making an exchange.

You brought something in. We identify it, research it when necessary, explain what we found, and make the best offer we reasonably can.

If you leave thinking the experience was much less dramatic than you expected, that is probably a good thing.

Reality television needs conflict, unusual characters, and last-second deals. A real coin shop needs accurate information, fair prices, and customers who feel comfortable coming back.

Learn more about selling coins, read our guide to identifying inherited coins, or visit our page about selling inherited and estate coin collections.

4.8 google reviews