SELL U.S. COINS

Most people aren’t sure what their coins are actually worth.

Some coins are only worth face value, while others can be worth significantly more depending on silver or gold content, rarity, condition, and collector demand.

At Oakton Coins & Collectibles, we evaluate U.S. coins every day — from common circulated coins to rare and valuable pieces. Whether you have a small group of coins or an entire collection, we can quickly determine what you have and what it’s worth, with no pressure to sell.

Types of U.S. Coins We Buy

We regularly purchase:

Silver coins (90% silver dimes, quarters, and half dollars)
Gold coins (pre-1933 U.S. gold coins)
Proof coins and proof sets
Uncirculated coins and mint sets
Rare and key date coins
Commemorative coins
Bullion coins (American Eagles and other U.S. Mint issues)

From a single coin to a large collection, we are always interested in taking a look.

What Makes Coins Valuable?

The value of a coin depends on several key factors:

Metal Content
Many U.S. coins contain silver or gold and are worth at least their melt value.

Date and Mint Mark
Certain years and mint locations are much scarcer than others.

Condition (Grade)
Coins in better condition are typically worth more, especially for collectible pieces.

Rarity
Some coins had low mintages or fewer surviving examples.

Collector Demand
Popularity among collectors can significantly affect value.

Silver Coins (90% “Junk Silver”)

One of the most common types of coins we see are pre-1965 U.S. silver coins.

These include dimes, quarters, and half dollars made of 90% silver. While they are often circulated and not considered rare individually, they still have value based on their silver content.

Prices for silver coins are influenced by the current market, but real-world buy and sell prices can vary based on demand, quantity, and market conditions.

Gold Coins

We regularly buy U.S. gold coins, especially those minted before 1933.

These coins can carry value based on both their gold content and their collectible (numismatic) value. Some trade close to their gold value, while others may be worth significantly more depending on rarity and condition.

Proof and Collector Coins

Proof coins and collector sets are specially made by the U.S. Mint with a higher level of detail and finish.

Some proof coins and mint sets carry collector value, while others trade closer to their metal value or original issue price. Value depends on the specific coins, condition, and demand.

We also evaluate coins that have been professionally graded by services such as PCGS and NGC, as well as raw (ungraded) coins.

How We Value Your Coins

We evaluate coins using multiple real-world market sources, including:

Dealer pricing guides
Recent auction results
Current gold and silver market conditions
Collector demand and market activity

Our goal is to give you a clear, accurate understanding of what your coins are worth in today’s market.

Sell Your Coins in Chicago

If you’re in Chicago, Skokie, Evanston, or nearby suburbs, bring your coins to Oakton Coins & Collectibles for a free evaluation.

We’ll explain exactly what you have and how it’s valued — whether you decide to sell or not.

No pressure, no obligation, just clear information from experienced buyers.

Frequently Asked Questions About Coins

Are my old coins worth anything?
Some coins are only worth face value, while others can be worth significantly more depending on metal content, rarity, and condition. We can quickly evaluate your coins and explain what you have.

What coins are made of silver?
Most U.S. dimes, quarters, and half dollars dated 1964 and earlier are made of 90% silver. These coins are commonly bought and sold based on their silver content.

Do all old coins have value?
No. Age alone does not determine value. Many older coins were produced in large quantities and are still common today.

Should I clean my coins before bringing them in?
No. Cleaning coins can reduce their value, especially for collectible pieces. It’s best to leave them in their original condition.

Do you buy coin collections?
Yes. We regularly purchase entire coin collections, including accumulations of silver coins, gold coins, and collector pieces.

Do you also buy paper money?
Yes. If you have paper currency, visit our U.S. paper money page for more information.